Whether waiting time is time worked depends on the circumstances. Facts may show that the employee was required to wait or they may show that the employee was waiting on the employer to be instructed to work. Such questions “must be determined in accordance with common sense and the general concept of work or employment.”
Examples:
An employee required to remain on
call or too close to work to use time freely
A stenographer who reads a book while waiting for dictation
A messenger who works a crossword puzzle while awaiting assignments
A fireman who plays checkers while waiting for alarms
A factory worker who waits while waiting for machinery to be repaired
Periods during which an employee is completely relieved from duty and which are long enough to enable him to use the time effectively for his own purposes are not hours worked. Whether the time is long enough to enable him to use the time effectively for his own purposes depends upon all of the facts and circumstances of the case.
A real case: paid to be ready
The case: Armour & Co. v. Wantock, 323 U.S. 126 (1944) (read the opinion)
The test the court used
- Is the waiting time mostly for the employer’s benefit, or for the worker’s?
- You do not have to be busy. Being ready and available can be the job.
What happened
Fire guards had to stay at the plant, on call. They could eat, sleep, listen to the radio and relax, but they could not leave.
How the court applied the test
- Limits on you: Staying on the premises kept a fire crew ready at all times.
- Employer benefit: Being ready was valuable even if no alarm went off.
- Free time: Having some leisure while waiting did not make it the workers’ own time.
The result
The Supreme Court agreed that the on-call time at issue was paid work time.
Keep in mind: This does not mean every hour spent at a workplace is paid, and it does not settle every on-call situation, especially when you can wait at home.
A recent case: time spent confined and on call in a truck
That case is the classic example of paid waiting. Here is a recent decision on a modern version of it.
The case: Montoya v. CRST Expedited, Inc., 88 F.4th 309 (1st Cir. 2023) (read the opinion on Justia)
Who the workers were and what they did
The workers were team truck drivers. One drove while the other rested in the truck’s sleeper berth, so the truck could keep moving almost nonstop.
What the employer did
The company did not count sleeper-berth time beyond eight hours in a 24-hour period, treating it as off-duty.
What the court decided
The court asked who the time mainly benefited. The confinement, the conditions, and how the resting time kept the truck moving for the company supported counting the time. A transportation-law label of “off-duty” did not decide what the wage law requires.
The result: The court upheld the drivers’ win on the sleeper-berth claim.
Keep in mind: This is a special case about sleep time in a moving truck and about minimum wage. It is not a rule for ordinary on-call time at home.
This is the kind of unpaid-overtime problem we help employees with, in courts across the country. If your workplace looks like the one in this case, tell us what happens on your shifts and we will tell you honestly whether you may be owed pay.
Free & Confidential — No Fee Unless We Win
Ready to Recover Your Unpaid Wages?
Overtime claims have strict legal deadlines. Contact Tran Law Firm today for a free, confidential case review with no obligation.
800 Town and Country Blvd Ste 500, Houston, TX 77024 — Nationwide Representation