If you have been getting “comp time” for working overtime hours in a work week, your employer may be violating the FLSA. A typical example is someone who works 55 hours in a workweek, and is told by their employer that they will give you 15 hours off then next week to “make up” for the extra hours worked. This is improper under the FLSA. If you are non-exempt, you are entitled to be paid overtime for any hours worked in excess of 40 hours per week. To calculate your overtime, please view Calculating Minimum Wage & Overtime. To determine whether you are exempt from overtime, please view Are you exempt or  non-exempt? .

The law behind it

We could not find a court decision about a private employer that handed out time off instead of overtime pay that was a good fit for this page, so we are not going to use a weak example. Here is what the law itself says, in plain words (29 U.S.C. § 207).

  • The rule: after 40 hours in a workweek, overtime must be paid in money, at one and a half times your regular rate.
  • The exception is narrow: only certain state and local government employers may give “comp time” instead of cash overtime, and only if specific conditions are met. The exception does not cover private employers.
  • A look-alike that is different: sending you home early on Friday so that you work 40 hours total that same week is not “comp time.” Saving up extra hours to use in a later week is the problem.

If your private employer gave you time off in a later week instead of paying overtime, you may be owed the cash.

A real case: a private employer that gave comp time instead of overtime pay

The rule above is easier to see in a real case. In this one, a private company tried to give time off instead of overtime pay, and a federal court said no.

The case: Williams v. Merle Pharmacy, Inc., No. 15-cv-1262 (C.D. Ill. Aug. 28, 2017) (read the ruling on Justia)

Who the worker was and what she did

Rhonda Williams worked full time, paid by the hour, for a pharmacy company and a related medical equipment company from about 2004 until she was fired in 2014. The ruling does not give her a more specific job title.

What the employer did

The companies had a written policy that there was generally no paid overtime. Instead, hours over 40 in a week were supposed to become “comp time,” meaning time off later. Employees were mostly left to track their own hours and shift their schedules so they would not go over 40.

What the court decided

The court held that private employers cannot pay for overtime with comp time. Comp time is allowed only for government employers under 29 U.S.C. § 207(o). Calling the extra time “comp time” or “flex time” did not take away the duty to pay overtime wages.

The result: The court granted Williams partial summary judgment on liability for her overtime claim under the FLSA and the Illinois wage law. It also awarded liquidated damages (extra damages) on the FLSA claim and held the company’s owner personally liable along with the companies. The amount of unpaid overtime was left for a jury to decide.

Keep in mind: This is a federal trial-court decision, so it does not bind other courts, and it did not set a final dollar amount. We have not checked whether it was appealed.

This is the kind of unpaid-overtime problem we help employees with. If your employer gives you time off instead of overtime pay, tell us how it works at your job and we will tell you honestly whether you may be owed pay.

Free & Confidential — No Fee Unless We Win

Ready to Recover Your Unpaid Wages?

Overtime claims have strict legal deadlines. Contact Tran Law Firm today for a free, confidential case review with no obligation.

800 Town and Country Blvd Ste 500, Houston, TX 77024 — Nationwide Representation