Many restaurants add an automatic “service charge” to large parties, private events or every check. Customers may assume it goes to the server. The law treats it differently from a tip, and the difference can affect your paycheck.
The rule
Under the Department of Labor’s regulations, a compulsory charge for service that the establishment imposes on a customer, such as a set percentage added to the bill, is not a tip (29 C.F.R. section 531.55). A tip is a voluntary payment determined by the customer. Because a service charge is not a tip, the employer cannot count it as a tip when claiming the tip credit.
Why it matters
- Tip credit. An employer who pays the lower $2.13 cash wage must show the employee actually received enough in real tips. A mandatory charge does not count toward that.
- Wages, not tips. If the employer passes a service charge on to employees, it is generally treated as wages, which can matter for overtime calculations.
- Who keeps it. Voluntary tips belong to employees, and a 2018 FLSA amendment bars employers and managers from keeping them. A mandatory charge is the employer’s revenue, so the employer may keep it unless a contract, policy or state law says otherwise.
Warning signs
- A menu or receipt that says “gratuity” for an automatic charge but the employer treats it as the house’s money.
- A tip credit taken for hours when the server mostly received service charges, not tips.
- Pay stubs that do not show how service charges were distributed.
What to do
Save receipts, schedules and pay stubs, and ask how service charges are handled. If your pay seems to fall below minimum wage after tips and charges are sorted out, speak with a wage and hour lawyer. The FLSA generally allows two years to sue for ordinary violations and three years for willful ones.
Watch the video
Watch on TikTok @overtimelawyer
Additional Resources:
- 29 C.F.R. section 531.55 (examples of amounts that are not tips) on Cornell LII
- 29 C.F.R. Part 531 on Cornell LII
- 29 C.F.R. section 531.52 (tips as wages) on Cornell LII
Follow @overtimelawyer on TikTok for more overtime and wage law updates.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every situation is different and laws change, so talk with a licensed attorney about your specific facts.