If your employer is paying you in cash, which is not being recorded, then your employer may be concealing a minimum wage or overtime violation. To determine the amount legally owed to you, it is necessary to compare the amounts actually paid with your hours. Your employer is required by law to keep records of all your hours and your pay. To learn more about the information that your employer is required to record, please view Are you being paid for all hours worked?.

A real case: records that hide unpaid overtime

The case: Dunlop v. Gray-Goto, Inc., 528 F.2d 792 (10th Cir. 1976) (read the opinion)

The test the court used

  • Overtime must be paid at one and a half times the regular rate.
  • The employer must keep accurate records of hours and pay.
  • Workers cannot sign away their overtime, and other benefits cannot be used to cancel it out.

What happened

The employer kept the real time cards but changed its payroll records so it looked as if straight pay already included overtime pay. It said the workers agreed to the setup and got other benefits.

How the court applied the test

  • Overtime pay: Straight-time pay is not time and a half.
  • Agreement and benefits: Workers agreeing, and receiving other benefits, did not wipe out the overtime owed.
  • Records: Keeping the true time cards did not excuse payroll records that made it look as though the overtime had been paid.
  • Good intentions: They did not erase the record-keeping violation.

The result

The appeals court sent the case back for fair relief and for a decision on whether the violation was willful.

Keep in mind: This case is about misleading records, not about cash itself. Being paid in cash is not the violation. Not paying overtime, or hiding it, is.

A recent case: cash payments and missing records

That case shows how records can hide unpaid overtime. Here is a recent decision where the records were missing and the pay was handled in cash and apps.

The case: Keefe v. Britt’s Bow Wow Boutique, Inc., No. 23-14024 (11th Cir. May 23, 2025) (read the opinion on Justia)

Who the workers were and what they did

Sydney Keefe worked in the day-to-day operation of a pet boarding and kennel business in Miami.

What the employer did

The company changed payroll systems, stopped reliably tracking hours, and made one-off cash or Venmo payments instead of keeping accurate overtime records.

What the court decided

Her testimony and other evidence supported the jury’s finding that she worked a lot of unpaid overtime and that the company knew. The company could not defeat the claim by pointing out that exact records did not exist, when it was the one required to keep them. The evidence also supported a finding that the violation was willful, and double damages.

The result: The verdict for the worker was upheld, including the overtime and the extra (liquidated) damages.

Keep in mind: This is an unpublished decision. Being paid in cash is not the violation by itself. The problem is unpaid overtime and missing records.

This is the kind of unpaid-overtime problem we help employees with, in courts across the country. If your workplace looks like the one in this case, tell us what happens on your shifts and we will tell you honestly whether you may be owed pay.

Free & Confidential — No Fee Unless We Win

Ready to Recover Your Unpaid Wages?

Overtime claims have strict legal deadlines. Contact Tran Law Firm today for a free, confidential case review with no obligation.

800 Town and Country Blvd Ste 500, Houston, TX 77024 — Nationwide Representation