Our recent lawsuits highlight the risk that companies face when applying auto-deduction policies for meal breaks and lunch breaks. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) allows employers to automatically deduct 30 minutes from compensable time for meal breaks for hourly employees. The meal break must be free from all job duties. If an employee has to work during a meal break, the employer must provide a way to report the work and correct the deduction.

View Page

Examples of auto-deduct lawsuits

 We were successful in filing and obtaining conditional certification on behalf of warehouse workers whose 30-minute lunch deduction occurred regardless of whether the meal break was taken. We alleged that employees were routinely prohibited from either taking an uninterrupted meal break or canceling the automatic deduction.

In another lawsuit, we sued the employer on behalf of custodians who were subjected to an automatic lunch deduction even though they worked through lunch.

In both cases, the employers implemented auto-deduct policies for meal breaks without any procedures to prevent supervisors from interrupting employees during their meal breaks or demanding that they work through their meal breaks in order to get the work done. The high workload and inadequate or inefficient staffing forced employees to shorten their meal breaks or skip them altogether. When the auto-deductions were applied, the employees were shorted up to 2.5 hours a week of overtime.

A real case: automatic meal-break deductions

The case: White v. Baptist Memorial Health Care Corp., 699 F.3d 869 (6th Cir. 2012) (read the opinion)

The test the court used

  • An automatic deduction is not illegal by itself.
  • The worker must show she did work during the meal break that went unpaid.
  • The employer must have known, or been told, that the work was going unpaid.

What happened

A hospital emergency-room nurse had 30 minutes deducted every shift for meals. The hospital had a form to report missed meals so she could be paid. She used it at first, then stopped.

How the court applied the test

  • Unpaid work: It takes more than the deduction itself to show that.
  • Knowledge: The court found that knowing a break was interrupted is different from knowing the work stayed unpaid, because the hospital had a way to fix it.
  • The reporting process: There was not enough proof that the hospital stopped her from using it or that she told it the work was going unpaid.

The result

The court approved the hospital’s win and the end of the group case. One judge disagreed.

Keep in mind: This is not a free pass for automatic deductions. An employer that blocks reporting, or knows work is going unpaid, can still be liable.

A recent case: meal breaks that were not really breaks

That case shows how an automatic deduction can be challenged. Here is a recent ruling about workers who said their breaks kept being interrupted.

The case: Cole v. Universal Health Care/Blumenthal, Inc., No. 1:24-cv-00576 (M.D.N.C. Aug. 15, 2025) (read the ruling on Justia)

Who the workers were and what they did

The workers were certified nursing assistants at five care facilities. They said their meal breaks were interrupted every day, that supervisors knew, and that they were told or pushed not to report missed breaks.

What the employer did

The company automatically took meal time out of their paychecks, whether or not they got to take a real break.

What the court decided

The court looked at the automatic deduction together with the claims of poor training, unclear instructions, and supervisors discouraging reports. It did not treat the deduction alone as the problem. That was enough to let a group of nursing assistants move forward together.

The result: The court granted conditional certification in part, limited to nursing assistants at the five facilities during a set time period.

Keep in mind: This is not a finding that the company broke the law. An automatic meal deduction is not illegal by itself. The claim is about work done during those breaks and the reporting practices around them.

This is the kind of unpaid-overtime problem we help employees with, in courts across the country. If your workplace looks like the one in this case, tell us what happens on your shifts and we will tell you honestly whether you may be owed pay.

Free & Confidential — No Fee Unless We Win

Ready to Recover Your Unpaid Wages?

Overtime claims have strict legal deadlines. Contact Tran Law Firm today for a free, confidential case review with no obligation.

800 Town and Country Blvd Ste 500, Houston, TX 77024 — Nationwide Representation